Hidden Risks: covered calls risks investors should know

It’s easy to think of covered calls as a simple way to pocket extra cash—almost like collecting rent on a house you already own. But this surface-level safety hides some very real covered calls risks that can stunt your portfolio's growth or even lead to unexpected losses. That premium you collect? It often doesn't come close to covering the dangers.

Why Covered Calls Are Not as Safe as You Think

The idea behind a covered call is straightforward enough. You own at least 100 shares of a stock, so you sell someone the right (an option) to buy those shares from you at a set price (the strike price) before a certain date. For that, you get paid an immediate cash premium. It’s this upfront income that makes the strategy so tempting, especially if you’re looking for consistent cash flow.

But this simple transaction masks a tricky trade-off. While the premium does give you a small cushion if the stock dips a little, it comes at a steep price. You're still on the hook for nearly all the downside if the stock tanks, but you completely give up any major gains if it skyrockets past your strike price.

The Five Critical Covered Calls Risks

Getting a handle on these trade-offs is non-negotiable before you put your money on the line. The perceived safety of covered calls can evaporate in a hurry when the market gets volatile. Let's peel back the layers on the five biggest risks every investor needs to confront:

• Major Market Downturns: The premium you collect is pocket change compared to the capital you can lose if a stock takes a nosedive.
• Missed Profit Opportunities: You cap your upside. This means you could miss out on huge gains if the stock rips higher after a positive earnings report or a market rally.
• Unexpected Early Assignment: The option buyer doesn't have to wait until expiration. They can exercise their right to buy your shares anytime, which can throw your whole plan off track.
• Poor Liquidity: If you're trading options on less popular stocks, you might find it difficult or expensive to get out of your position. You could get stuck.
• The High-Yield Trap: Chasing big premiums usually means selling calls on highly volatile stocks. That's where a small win can quickly turn into a massive loss, wiping out all your hard-earned income.

A covered call doesn't magically erase the risks of owning a stock; it just changes the potential outcomes. You’re trading an unknown, unlimited upside for a small, known premium.

By digging into these dangers, you can build a much clearer and more realistic view of this popular strategy. It’s all about making smarter, more informed decisions for your portfolio.

The Market Risk No Premium Can Truly Cover

This is the big one. Of all the risks in covered calls, this is the one that catches people sleeping. The little bit of income you collect from selling the call option creates an illusion of safety, but it's just a small cushion—not a helmet—in a real market downturn.

Let's be clear: you still own the stock. That means you are still exposed to nearly all of its downside. The premium you get isn't for downside protection; it’s your compensation for giving up the stock's potential upside. If your stock tanks, that small premium payment will feel like a drop in the ocean compared to your capital losses.

A Real-World Scenario of Downside Risk

Imagine you own 100 shares of a company, XYZ. You bought them for $100 a share, putting your total investment at $10,000. To squeeze some income out of it, you sell a covered call with a $105 strike price and collect a $2 per share premium. That’s $200 in your pocket.

Because of that premium, your breakeven price is now $98 ($100 cost basis - $2 premium).

But what happens if the stock drops hard? Let's say it falls to $80 a share, a 20% nosedive. Here’s what your position looks like now:

• Stock Loss: Your 100 shares are now worth only $8,000, which is an unrealized loss of $2,000.
• Net Position: When you factor in the $200 premium you collected, your total loss is $1,800.

That $200 premium barely made a dent in a $2,000 loss. This is where the strategy shows its weakness. It offers almost no meaningful protection against a serious price drop, which is easily the most critical risk to understand. This is also where bigger portfolio dangers, like sequence of returns risk, come into play, as large drawdowns can severely impact your long-term financial health.

Selling a covered call does not remove the potential for major losses; it just slightly lowers your cost basis. You are still fully exposed to a market crash or a company-specific disaster.

This is probably the single biggest reason newcomers damage their portfolios. They think they've found a "safe" income strategy, but the data tells a different story. Looking back at the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), portfolios using covered calls didn't fare much better than simple stock/bond mixes.

In fact, one analysis showed a hypothetical portfolio with a 20% allocation to covered calls actually had bigger drawdowns than a standard 60/40 portfolio during the GFC. It’s a stark reminder of the trade-offs you make when balancing yield and total return.

Understanding the High Price of Capped Gains

While a falling stock price is an obvious danger, one of the most significant—and often underestimated—risks in covered calls is opportunity cost.

When you sell a call option, you’re making a firm commitment to sell your shares at the strike price if the buyer wants them. This move effectively puts a hard ceiling on how much you can profit, no matter how high the stock flies.

This profit cap becomes a real liability during a strong bull market or when your stock suddenly rips higher on unexpected good news, like a blowout earnings report or a breakthrough product launch. The premium you collected might feel like a win at the time, but it can look like pocket change compared to the massive gains you left on the table.

The Pain of a Breakout Stock

Let’s walk through a classic example. Imagine you own 100 shares of a promising tech company, ACME Inc., which you bought at $50 per share. The stock has been trading flat for a while, so you decide to sell a covered call with a $55 strike price. You collect a $1.50 premium per share, pocketing a quick $150.

Your maximum profit is now locked in. If the stock price stays below $55, you keep your shares and the $150 premium. If it rises above $55, your shares get called away, and your total gain will be $650 ($500 from the stock moving from $50 to $55, plus the $150 premium).

A month later, ACME announces a game-changing new product, and the stock price explodes to $80 per share.

• Your Outcome: Your shares are called away at $55. You made your maximum profit of $650.
• A Buy-and-Hold Investor's Outcome: Their shares are now worth $8,000, representing a $3,000 gain on paper.

You secured a small, guaranteed profit but missed out on an additional $2,350 of upside. This is the painful trade-off at the very heart of covered calls. The concept of what is moneyness in options becomes critical here; as the stock price soared, your in-the-money call obligated you to sell far below its new market value.

Opportunity cost is the invisible tax on covered call writing. The small, consistent income you generate can be completely overshadowed by the exponential gains you forfeit on your best-performing assets.

Long-Term Underperformance Is a Known Issue

This isn't just a hypothetical problem; it's a well-documented pattern. Covered call strategies have historically underperformed the broader market over long periods, precisely because they trim the tops off the best market runs.

Take a look at how this plays out in the real world. The table below compares the S&P 500's performance with the S&P 500 BuyWrite Index, which tracks a systematic covered call strategy on the index.

Covered Call vs Buy-and-Hold Performance in Bull Markets

Year	S&P 500 Return	S&P 500 BuyWrite Index Return	Performance Gap
2017	+21.8%	+10.9%	-10.9%
2019	+31.5%	+17.3%	-14.2%
2020	+18.4%	+9.5%	-8.9%
2021	+28.7%	+20.1%	-8.6%

As you can see, in years with strong market gains, the covered call strategy consistently lagged, leaving significant money on the table.

For example, long-term data shows that from late 1995 through 2021, an investor in an S&P 500 BuyWrite Index would have seen an annualized return of 6.6%. In contrast, a simple buy-and-hold S&P 500 investor would have earned 9.2%. This gap means the buy-and-hold investor would have accumulated more than double the wealth over that 26-year span.

To get a broader perspective on how speculative strategies influence outcomes, it's helpful to compare them to concepts like spread betting in financial markets, where understanding defined risk and reward is also key.

Navigating Early Assignment and Liquidity Traps

Beyond the obvious market ups and downs, a couple of sneaky technical risks can trip up your covered call strategy: early assignment and poor liquidity.

Both can catch you completely off guard, turning what looked like a simple income trade into a real headache.

The Surprise of Early Assignment

First up is the risk of early assignment. Most people selling options figure the buyer will just wait until the expiration date to make a move. But here's the catch: the buyer of an American-style option (which includes all U.S. stock options) can exercise their option and buy your shares at the strike price any time they want before it expires.

This isn’t usually a random event. It often happens for a very specific reason, and that reason is almost always a dividend.

If your stock is about to pay out a dividend, an option holder with an in-the-money call might exercise it right before the ex-dividend date. Why? To grab that dividend payment for themselves. This forces you to sell your shares earlier than you planned, which could trigger an unexpected tax bill and mess up your long-term plans for that stock. To get a better handle on how this all works, you can dig into the details of what happens when options expire and where assignment fits into the picture.

The Hidden Cost of Illiquidity

The second technical trap is liquidity risk. Think of it like trying to sell a house. A standard three-bedroom home in a busy suburb has a ton of potential buyers, so you can sell it fast at a competitive price. But a weird, custom-built mansion way out in the middle of nowhere? Far fewer buyers, making it much tougher to get a fair price.

Options are the exact same way. Options on popular, heavily traded stocks like Apple or Tesla have high liquidity. The price gap between what buyers are willing to pay (the bid) and what sellers are asking (the ask) is usually just a few pennies. This is called the bid-ask spread.

But options on smaller, less-traded stocks are often illiquid. They have a wide bid-ask spread, which basically acts as a hidden fee. If that spread is too wide, you might have to settle for a much lower premium to sell your call. Or worse, you might have to pay way more than you'd like to buy it back if you want to close the position early. This can leave you stuck in a trade you don't want anymore, forcing you to either ride it out to expiration or take a loss just to get out.

The chart below shows how a covered call strategy can perform over the long haul compared to just holding the stock, illustrating how those capped gains add up.

This really drives home the opportunity cost we talked about earlier. While covered calls are great for generating income, they can seriously lag behind a simple buy-and-hold strategy when the market is climbing.

Why Chasing High Yields Often Leads to Losses

It’s one of the oldest temptations in options trading. You spot a stock with an unusually high premium, dangling the promise of a massive annualized return. It feels like a sure thing.

But this “yield chasing” is one of the most common and damaging mistakes a covered call investor can make.

That big, juicy premium isn’t free money—it’s a warning sign. The market is screaming at you that the underlying stock is extremely volatile and carries a significant risk of a huge, unpredictable price swing. In other words, you're being paid more because there's a much higher chance you’ll lose your shirt on the stock itself.

This direct link between high yields and high risk usually ends badly. Investors chasing these returns often find that their capital losses from the stock tanking completely wipe out the income they collected from the premium.

The Myth of the High-Yield Cushion

Let's say you sell a call on a volatile biotech stock and collect a premium that looks like a 30% annualized return. Fantastic, right?

Not so fast. A week later, the company announces disappointing clinical trial results, and the stock price plummets 40% overnight. Your premium income is gone in a flash, leaving you with a huge net loss and a tough decision about what to do with your now-damaged stock.

The core lesson here is that there's no free lunch in options. A high yield is a direct reflection of the market's expectation of turbulence, tying your potential income to a much higher risk of losing your underlying capital.

This isn’t just a theory; the data backs it up. Empirical research on covered call strategies shows a clear trend: the higher the targeted yield, the worse the overall performance.

One comprehensive study of S&P 500 strategies found that from 2011 to 2023, a strategy targeting just a 6% yield resulted in an annualized loss of -3.1% after costs. The performance got even worse as the yield targets went up, proving just how dangerous this approach can be. You can dive into the full findings yourself to see how higher yields correlate with lower returns.

A Smarter Approach to Premium

Instead of chasing the highest yield you can find, a more sustainable strategy focuses on balancing income with smart risk management. Here’s how to reframe your thinking:

• Focus on Quality: Sell calls on stable, blue-chip stocks you actually want to own for the long term. The premiums will be smaller, but the risk of a catastrophic price drop is also much lower.
• Target Realistic Yields: Aim for modest, consistent returns instead of swinging for the fences. This approach helps you build wealth steadily without exposing your portfolio to a ton of unnecessary volatility.
• Understand Implied Volatility (IV): Recognize that high IV is what creates those big premiums in the first place. While it can boost your income, it’s also a bright red flag signaling a greater probability of the stock making a large move against you.

At the end of the day, successful covered call writing isn't about squeezing every last dollar out of every premium. It's about generating consistent income while carefully protecting the capital you've worked so hard to build.

How to Intelligently Manage Covered Call Risks

Knowing the risks of covered calls is one thing. Actually managing them is what separates the consistently profitable traders from everyone else. Instead of just reacting to whatever the market throws at you, a proactive game plan helps you find the sweet spot between generating income and protecting your capital.

The foundation for smart risk management is laid long before you sell a single contract. It starts with the stock itself.

A core principle I live by is this: only write calls on high-quality companies you’d be happy to own for the long haul, even if the share price takes a temporary hit. This simple mindset keeps you from chasing huge premiums on speculative, high-flying stocks that can blow up in your face.

A Framework for Strategic Call Writing

Your goal should be to shift from simply collecting premiums to making strategic, calculated trade-offs. This means carefully picking your option parameters—the strike price and expiration date—to match your market outlook and how much risk you're comfortable with. Discipline here is everything.

I think of it as a three-legged stool:

• Strike Price Selection: Choosing a strike price further out-of-the-money gets you a smaller premium, but it gives your stock more runway to climb before it gets called away. This is your primary defense against opportunity cost.
• Expiration Date Management: Shorter-dated options, usually in the 30-45 day range, are my go-to. They shrink the window for market chaos and let you pivot your strategy more often as conditions change.
• Position Monitoring: Covered calls are not a "set it and forget it" strategy. You have to watch your positions. If a stock drops hard, be ready to buy back the call to avoid locking in losses on your shares.

The most effective way to manage covered call risks is to treat each trade not as a simple income generator, but as a dynamic part of your broader investment thesis for the underlying stock.

Knowing when to cut bait or adjust is a skill that takes time to develop. If your stock shoots up way faster than you expected, you might consider buying back the call—even if it means taking a small loss—to uncap your upside.

On the flip side, if the stock falls, you can "roll" the option. This means closing your current call and opening a new one at a lower strike price and a later date, which lets you collect another premium and effectively lower your cost basis on the stock.

Mastering these techniques is what leads to long-term success. For a much deeper dive into this, check out our detailed guide on the best practices for risk management. By focusing on quality stocks, carefully structuring your trades, and staying engaged, you can navigate the inherent risks of covered calls with much more confidence.

Common Questions About Covered Call Risks

Let’s tackle some of the most frequent questions investors have about the potential downsides of writing covered calls.

Does a Covered Call Protect Me in a Market Crash?

No, not really. It offers a tiny bit of protection, but it’s nowhere near enough to save you from a real market downturn. The premium you collect is just a small buffer against much larger losses.

Think about it this way: if you get a $2 premium for a call on a $100 stock, your breakeven price is now $98. If that stock suddenly plummets to $70, you've still lost $28 a share. In a serious crash, your losses will look almost identical to a regular buy-and-hold investor's.

What Is the Biggest Risk for Long-Term Investors?

Without a doubt, the single biggest risk is opportunity cost. By capping your gains, you're essentially forced to sell your best-performing stocks whenever the market rallies.

Over many years, this consistent profit-capping can cause your portfolio to dramatically underperform a simple buy-and-hold strategy, resulting in far less accumulated wealth than you might have otherwise achieved.

Can I Lose More Than My Initial Investment?

Nope. Because you already own the underlying shares, the "covered" part of the name means your risk is defined. Your absolute maximum loss is what you paid for the stock, minus the premium you collected.

This is a world away from selling "naked" calls, where you could face unlimited risk. But it’s crucial to remember: you can still lose your entire initial investment if the stock’s price falls all the way to zero.

---

Stop gambling and start making data-driven decisions. Strike Price gives you real-time probability metrics to balance safety and income, turning guesswork into a repeatable strategy. Find your next winning trade today.